Two very different plush personalities
Choosing between Mr. Lobster and Black Sheep comes down to what you want the plush to do. Mr. Lobster is a statement piece—a bright red crustacean with a striped belly that works as a novelty gift or a playful companion. Black Sheep is a compact, classic comfort toy with a black head and arms against a fluffy white body, sized for little hands. Neither is a better plush overall; they simply serve different moments.
The catalog gives us enough to compare size, character, and price, but it does not confirm safety certifications, washing instructions, or exact materials. Where that information is missing, we will say so rather than guess. Use the confirmed facts below to match each plush to your recipient and purpose.
What the catalog confirms about each plush
- Black Sheep: Black Sheep measures 6″ L × 3″ W and is described as perfectly sized for little hands. This small footprint makes Black Sheep a natural first plush or a portable comfort toy for young children.

Black Sheep - Mr. Lobster: Mr. Lobster measures 15″ L × 6″ W and has a vibrant red hue with an orange and white striped pattern on his belly. The larger size and bold coloring make Mr. Lobster a display-friendly novelty gift rather than a pocket-sized comforter.

Mr. Lobster
Size and character: which fits your situation
- Black Sheep: At 6″ L × 3″ W, Black Sheep is the petite counterpart to the larger Sweet Black Sheep. The contrasting black head and arms against a fluffy white body give it a classic, gentle look. It suits bedtime snuggles, imaginary play, and small hands that need a light, easy-to-hold plush.
- Mr. Lobster: At 15″ L × 6″ W, Mr. Lobster is a substantial plush with a soft, cuddly texture and a distinctive red color with orange and white stripes on the belly. The catalog calls him a lovable little gentleman. He works well as a novelty gift, a room decoration, or a cuddle buddy for older children and adults who like quirky characters.
Price and value: what you pay for
The catalog lists Black Sheep at USD 16.50 (comparison price USD 22.00) and Mr. Lobster at USD 18.82 (comparison price USD 26.50). Both are discounted from their comparison prices, but the absolute cost is close. The real difference is what you get for the money: Black Sheep offers a small, classic comfort toy, while Mr. Lobster offers a much larger, more decorative plush. If you are buying for a small child, Black Sheep's lower price and hand-friendly size may be the practical choice. If you want a gift with visual impact, Mr. Lobster's size and character justify the small price gap.
What the catalog does not confirm
Neither product record includes safety certifications, recommended age ranges, washing instructions, or material composition. The Black Sheep record does not list care or safety evidence, and the Mr. Lobster record likewise omits those details. This does not mean the plushes lack those features—it simply means the supplied information does not confirm them. Before buying for a very young child or someone with allergies, check the product label or contact Bukowski Bears directly for current safety and care guidance. Avoid assuming either plush is machine washable or suitable for unsupervised play without that confirmation.
A simple way to decide
- Choose Black Sheep if: You need a small, affordable comfort plush for a young child, a portable bedtime companion, or a gentle classic design. The 6″ L × 3″ W size and USD 16.50 price make it an easy everyday choice.
- Choose Mr. Lobster if: You want a larger, eye-catching novelty gift with a soft texture and a distinctive red-and-striped look. The 15″ L × 6″ W size and USD 18.82 price suit a statement plush for older children or adults.



